For the second, since Geoff's charisma isn't really noticeable by itself, it probably wouldn't cause an Echo just by having effect on Melissa. Upon discussion we decided that maybe it could if she consciously manages to realize that this is ~the most charismatic person she's ever seen~ or whatnot, but it's still somewhat iffy and probably more along the lines of causing a memory of being affected by this ability.
Perhaps this Echo would be better for a little further down the road? Unless you have a better idea, of course.
no subject
For the second, since Geoff's charisma isn't really noticeable by itself, it probably wouldn't cause an Echo just by having effect on Melissa. Upon discussion we decided that maybe it could if she consciously manages to realize that this is ~the most charismatic person she's ever seen~ or whatnot, but it's still somewhat iffy and probably more along the lines of causing a memory of being affected by this ability.
Perhaps this Echo would be better for a little further down the road? Unless you have a better idea, of course.